For the elite high school quarterbacks in the country, the opportunity to play quarterback at one of the bigtime college football programs is a dream come true. One major factor in making the final decision on which program gets the signature on the letter of intent is the degree to which that individual player will be prepared for the next level (the NFL).
The high-powered programs like Florida, Oklahoma, Miami and USC are just a few of the major BSC schools that elite high school quarterbacks consider, and why not? These teams are known for their juggernaut offenses, and they are consistently in the hunt for a national championship. College FootBlog takes a deeper look into the progress of the top performing quarterbacks from the NFL and where those QBs played their college ball.
If you are a coach or a parent of an elite QB, the you may want to take a hard look at the numbers because you’ll probably be very surprised. For a number of reasons, which we will cover later, the major programs typically do not groom their top-tier signal callers for the NFL. Let’s take a look at the passer ratings from the last season.
Purdue’s Drew Brees was the Superbowl MVP and the top-rated QB in the NFL last year, with a QB Rating of 109.6. Brett Favre was a close second and is a sure-fire, first ballot Hall of Famer, and he played at Southern Miss.
Phillip Rivers was the 3rd-ranked QB last year and has been a dominant player since his arrival in 2004, but NC State is not exactly known as Quarterback-U. Aaron Rodgers was #4 and played at Cal, which doesn’t have the glamor of USC, but he outperformed his former rivals from LA last season. Matt Schaub was ranked seventh and hails from the University of Virginia.
The other three QBs in the top ten really dispel the idea that you have to go to a bigtime program to prepare for the NFL. Fifth-ranked Ben Roethlisberger went to Miami–no, not that ‘Miami’…Miami of Ohio. Eighth-ranked Tony Romo and 10th-ranked Kurt Warner played Division IAA (or FCS for those who are up on the new abbreviations) at Eastern Illinois and Northern Iowa, respectively.
Now, let’s take a look at the lowest ranked QBs from last year’s NFL season. Five of the worst eight QBs in the NFL last season were from major programs, including #32 (the worst) first-round bust JaMarcus Russell from LSU. Former USC quarterbacks Matt Cassel and Mark Sanchez were numbers 25 and 28.
When digging into the numbers it really should not come as a huge surprise. Afterall, the quarterbacks at the major programs typically have a bigtime advantage with their receiving corps versus the opposing secondaries. For example, in Stafford’s last season at Georgia, he had 6’2″ and 2nd round pick Mohamed Massaquoi and soon to be first rounder AJ Green, who is 6’4″ and could be the best wideout in the country this year.
Even in the SEC, which is widely known for being the best conference in college football, the dominant programs have bigger, faster and stronger WRs, creating bigger windows to throw into and much more room for error.
In the NFL, it is typically the cornerbacks that are the fastest players on the field, and while they may be at a disadvantage in size, the talent pool is much smaller, and those large windows to complete passes are not only smaller, but they also close very quickly. In the NFL, a ball delivered a split-second too early or too late is the difference between a completion and a pick-six for the defense.
The QBs at the lesser-known programs have to deal with a more balanced and level playing field and often do not have this colossal advantage with their receivers, forcing them to make better reads and to thread the needle, instead of throwing to an area.
In the end, there are a few low-ranked QBs that could easily turn things around. After all, Mark Sanchez and Matthew Stafford were only rookies last season, but the trend is quite staggering when you take away all the glamor and simply look at production on the field. For the time being (and seemingly for the immediate future), it is the underdogs that continue to lead the way.